You've probably heard the advice that nails need to "breathe" between manicures, but is this actually true? Let's explore what science says about nail health, and whether taking a break from gel, dip, extensions, or regular polish is really necessary.
Can Nails Actually Breathe?
Firstly, nails don’t technically breathe. Your nails get nutrients and oxygen from the bloodstream, not from air exposure. The idea of nails "breathing" is more about giving your nails a rest from constant chemical exposure and physical stress caused by manicures.
According to dermatologist Dr. Dana Stern, nails "derive oxygen and nutrients from the blood supply and not the air"
Gel and Dip Manicures: Do You Need a Break?
Gel and dip manicures involve stronger chemical processes and longer-lasting wear. The removal process, typically involving acetone soaking or drilling, can weaken and thin nails if done too frequently.
A 2020 survey study published in the National Library of Medicine analyzed responses from over 2,100 women regarding their experiences with gel polish. Common issues included: Decreased toughness (30.2%), Splitting (25.7%), White spots (8.1%), Surface grooves (6.6%). Most changes occurred after removal, not during wear. The study concluded that improper removal techniques, frequent manicures, and a lack of rest periods can significantly weaken nail health.
Recommendation: This reinforces the importance of careful removal techniques. It's beneficial to periodically rest your nails, ideally one week every two to three months, to restore moisture and strength after removal. This is sometimes known as a "nail cycling" approach.
Nail Extensions: Taking Care of Natural Nails
Extensions, such as acrylics or Gel-X, require filing and adhesives that may stress the natural nail. Similar to Gel and Dip Manicures, improper or frequent removal of extensions can lead to weakened, brittle nails, or damage the nail bed.
Regular Polish: Less Stress, But Still Needs Rest?
Regular nail polish, though less harsh, still involves chemical exposure. Continuous use of polish and remover can still dry out nails, making them prone to breakage and peeling.
FAQs About Nail Breathing and Breaks
Q: If I just leave my nails alone, will they recover on their own?
A: Leaving nails bare is a helpful break, but damage like thinning or peeling doesn't "heal" — it grows out. The nail plate is made of keratin and has no living cells, so it can't repair itself like skin. Support healthy regrowth with hydration, gentle care, and protective products.
Q: Am I taking breaks if my polish stays on for months?
A: No — if you're only removing your polish once every several months, your nails aren't getting frequent enough hydration breaks. Even if your polish seems intact, nails still benefit greatly from occasional removal, allowing rehydration and assessment of nail health.
Q: Does having polish constantly weaken nails?
A: Constant polish use can dry and weaken nails over time, especially with frequent polish remover exposure. Short breaks help restore hydration.
Q: Can I strengthen nails without taking breaks?
A: Regular application of nourishing cuticle oils and strengtheners can help, but periodic breaks remain beneficial for overall nail health.
Q: How long should a nail break last?
A: Ideally, take a few days to one week off polish every one to two months, depending on the type of manicure you regularly receive.
Q: Are some nail treatments healthier than others?
A: Regular polish is generally gentler than gel, dip, or extensions. Gel and dip treatments should be spaced out more, with attentive care during removal.
Best Practices for Nail Health
-
Hydrate regularly with cuticle oils (like Theniya’s nourishing blends).
-
Safe removals to minimize damage as you change manicures.
-
Give occasional breaks to maintain optimal nail health.
Taking short, regular breaks between manicures ensures your nails remain strong, beautiful, and healthy in the long run.
Keep your nails at their best. Explore Theniya’s products for hydrated, happy nails.
